1986 NHL Supplemental Draft
ROUND: 1 | 2 
Round 2
No.TeamPlayerPos.Last teamLeagueNationality
5.DetroitRob DoyleDColorado CollegeWCHACanada
 Los AngelesInvalid Claim(picked Grant Paranica, ineligible for entering school after age 20)
6.New JerseyTim BarakettRWHarvard ECACCanada
7.PittsburghRandy TaylorDHarvard ECACCanada
8.BuffaloJohn CullenCBoston UniversityHockey EastCanada
9.TorontoArt FitzGeraldGTrinity CollegeECAC-IIIUSA
10.VancouverDavid GourlieDDenver WCHACanada
11.WinnipegChris LevasseurCAlaska-AnchorageNCAAUSA
12.N.Y. RangersGary EmmonsCNorthern MichiganWCHACanada
13.St. LouisMarty RausDNortheasternHockey EastCanada
14.HartfordJoe TracyRWOhio State CCHAUSA
15.MinnesotaBrian McKeeDBowling GreenCCHACanada
16.BostonChris OlsonGDenver WCHAUSA
17.ChicagoDave RandallDNorthern MichiganWCHACanada
18.MontrealRandy ExelbyGLake SuperiorCCHACanada
19.CalgarySteve MacSwainRW MinnesotaWCHAUSA
20.N.Y. IslandersGary KruzichGBowling GreenCCHAUSA
21.QuebecMike NatyshakRWBowling GreenCCHACanada
22.WashingtonSteve CousinsDAlberta CWUAACanada
23.EdmontonPeter HeinzeDLowell Hockey EastUSA
NOTE: Philadelphia passed on its opportunity to make the No. 23 pick.